Skip to content

GRF · Disaster and Crisis Governance

Decision analysis under uncertainty for disaster and crisis governance

Decision analysis structures choices made under uncertainty and time pressure: options, consequences, probabilities and values. In crisis governance it frames warning thresholds, evacuation orders, resource allocation and the trade-offs that leaders face before the facts are clear.

01Register

Key facts.

Method recordSTEM method
  1. MbinuUchambuzi wa maamuzi chini ya kutokuwa na uhakika
  2. Applied inDisaster and Crisis Governance
  3. Canonical pageSTEM Commons
02Application

What decision analysis under uncertainty does here.

Decision analysis under uncertainty provides structured methods for choosing among options when outcomes are uncertain and objectives conflict. It makes trade-offs and value judgements explicit. In disaster and crisis and critical infrastructure, decision analysis helps choose actions that perform acceptably across interconnected risks and uncertain futures. It clarifies when to act now and when to keep options open. The canonical description is on the STEM Commons.

Warning thresholds and false alarms

Decision trees compare the cost of acting on a warning that proves false with the cost of failing to act, making the threshold choice explicit for the authority that sets it.

Pre-agreed triggers for action

Forecast thresholds are linked to actions and responsibilities in advance, so that decisions in an event follow a protocol rather than improvisation.

Structured decisions in exercises

Exercise scenarios record which decisions leaders took, on what information and when, so after-action reviews can examine reasoning as well as outcomes.

03Monitor

Uncertainty analysis.

The screen a team would use to follow this method: its measures, states and decisions. Names are examples and values are illustrative.

Uncertainty analysis

Crisis governance · Decision analysis · Run R-0034

Sensitivity rankedGRF · Disaster and Crisis Governance

Total-order sensitivity

Output distribution

Inputs

Agencies with clear mandatesBeta of agencies, statedexpert elicitation
Warnings issued on timeLognormal of warnings, statedexpert elicitation
Exercises heldLognormalexercises, statedexpert elicitation
After-action items closedBeta of items, statedexpert elicitation
Uncertainty analysis: the screen’s structure, terms and states for Crisis governance.Example names and illustrative values; a design, not a record or a live system.
04Data

What the method consumes.

Datasets and records used by decision analysis under uncertainty on this platform, with the role each plays and the label its values carry. Sources are listed in the source register.

DataJukumuLabel
Warning logs and event recordsVerification of past decisionsIMEONEKANA
Hazard forecasts and probabilitiesInputs to thresholdsUTABIRI
Cost and impact estimatesConsequences of optionsIMEKADIRIWA
Exercise decision logsDecision process evidenceIMERIPOTIWA
05Policy scenarios

Compare instruments: rules, incentives and information.

Three families of instruments side by side against the baseline, each with its own lag and adoption speed, under the coverage and compliance you set; effect sizes are teaching values to replace with evidence. Scenario: named assumptions about the future, not a forecast.

Controls

Baseline trend of the outcome
2.0% a year
Coverage of the instrument
70%
Uzingatiaji wa kanuni
75%
Effect size, against the teaching value
100%
Years ahead
20 years

Readouts

Largest reduction at the horizon
Regulation
Its reduction against the baseline
21%
Numbers, methods and sources
YearHali ya msingiRegulationEconomic incentiveInformation and capacity
0100.099.598.899.1
1102.0101.2100.199.8
2104.0102.5101.199.9
3106.1103.5101.6100.0
4108.2103.7101.8100.7
5110.4103.2101.7102.1
6112.6102.0101.6103.9
7114.9100.4101.6105.9
8117.299.2102.1108.0
9119.598.6102.9110.1
10121.998.9104.2112.3
11124.399.7105.7114.5
12126.8101.1107.4116.8
13129.4102.7109.4119.2
14131.9104.5111.4121.6
15134.6106.5113.5124.0
16137.3108.5115.7126.5
17140.0110.7118.0129.0
18142.8112.9120.4131.6
19145.7115.1122.8134.2
20148.6117.4125.2136.9

Mbinu

  1. Tools of government Hood (1983), The Tools of Government, Macmillan
  2. Carrots, sticks and sermons Bemelmans-Videc, Rist and Vedung (1998), Transaction
  3. Diffusion of innovations Rogers (2003), Diffusion of Innovations, Free Press
  4. Uncertainty fan (parameter Monte Carlo) Spiegelhalter, Pearson and Short (2011), Visualising uncertainty about the future, Science 333
  5. One-at-a-time sensitivity (tornado) Saltelli and others (2008), Global Sensitivity Analysis: The Primer, Wiley

Data

The model runs on the teaching values set by the controls. To calibrate it for a place, read it against these admitted layers and series, which this page’s map can draw:

  • Borders Natural Earth
  • Cities Natural Earth
Compare instruments: rules, incentives and information. Illustrative teaching model: it runs on the values set by the controls, not on measured data. Methods: Tools of government (Hood (1983), The Tools of Government, Macmillan); Carrots, sticks and sermons (Bemelmans-Videc, Rist and Vedung (1998), Transaction); Diffusion of innovations (Rogers (2003), Diffusion of Innovations, Free Press).
06Validation

How results are checked.

Analyses are checked through sensitivity analysis, peer review and stakeholder scrutiny. Retrospective review compares decisions with outcomes.

CheckHow it is done
Options statedEach analysis lists the options considered, including doing nothing
Values explicitTrade-offs between lives, cost and disruption are stated, not hidden in weights
Hindsight separatedReviews judge decisions on the information available at the time

Results depend on elicited probabilities and preferences that may be biased. Deep uncertainty can make expected value comparisons misleading.

07Utekelezaji

From mandate to evaluation, by pillar.

The steps an instrument takes from mandate to evaluation, each with the pillar that runs it, and the decisions that stay with the authority. Teaching model with stated illustrative values, not a prediction.

  1. Mandate and problem framing Competent authority (outside the programme)
    A competent authority frames the problem and the mandate under its own rules. Howlett, Ramesh and Perl (2009)
  2. Evidence and system model Foundry
    The system is modelled with its feedbacks, data and stated limits. OECD (2014), principle 2
  3. Options appraised with scenarios Foundry
    Instruments are compared under scenarios, with uncertainty shown. Hood (1983)
  4. Exercise with stakeholders Universe
    The options are tested in an exercise with those who would implement and bear them. OECD (2014), principle 3
  5. Standard or guidance drafted Nexus Standards
    What works is codified as a standard or guidance, open to comment. Nexus Standards process
  6. Decision by the authority Competent authority (outside the programme)
    The authority decides, outside the programme, with the evidence on record. Howlett, Ramesh and Perl (2009)
  7. Capacity and training Risk Academy
    Those who implement are trained on the decided instrument and its data. Sendai Framework (2015), priority 2
  8. Monitoring and public report Reports
    Indicators are published with sources, limits and corrections. OECD (2014), principle 5
  9. Evaluation and revision Nexus Standards
    Results return to the standard and the model: the cycle closes. Howlett, Ramesh and Perl (2009)

Mbinu

  1. Policy cycle Howlett, Ramesh and Perl (2009), Studying Public Policy, Oxford University Press
  2. Governance of critical risks OECD (2014), Recommendation of the Council on the Governance of Critical Risks
  3. Layered drawing of directed graphs Sugiyama, Tagawa and Toda (1981), IEEE SMC 11
From mandate to evaluation, by pillar: the steps as recorded, each with its pillar; sources as cited on each step.
09Instruments and commitments

Instruments, mandates and commitments.

The instruments, mandates, actors and accountability arrangements a policymaker, diplomat or development agency works with, citing the agreements that set them. Structures follow the frameworks named. Any state or progress drawn is illustrative, not a record.

Mandates and agreements over time

The agreements that set mandates and commitments on decision analysis under uncertainty for disaster and crisis governance, from adoption to their current horizon.

  1. 2015Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk ReductionUNDRR
  2. 20152030 Agenda and the Sustainable Development GoalsUnited Nations
  3. 2030Horizon of the 2030 Agenda and the Sendai FrameworkUnited Nations
Adoption years of the agreements named; the texts and their bodies are the authority. Chosen from the page’s fields.
Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction · UNDRRParis Agreement · UNFCCC2030 Agenda and the Sustainable Development Goals · United NationsInternational Health Regulations · WHO
10Usimamizi

Who maintains the method.

Systemic Risk Management stewards decision analysis under uncertainty for the Consortium and reviews how it is applied across platforms.

12Maswali

Questions and answers.

What are the limits of decision analysis under uncertainty in this field?
Results depend on elicited probabilities and preferences that may be biased. Deep uncertainty can make expected value comparisons misleading.
How are results checked?
Analyses are checked through sensitivity analysis, peer review and stakeholder scrutiny. Retrospective review compares decisions with outcomes.
Are the values on this page real?
The data names, roles and checks are real descriptions of practice. The canvas shows a design of the method’s use, not a run; no result is reported here.
Where else is this method applied?
The canonical method page lists every platform that applies it.
RipotiChangia

Changia ushahidi kutoka ukurasa huu.

Reports ni chapisho la kila robo mwaka la Muungano. Unachojua kuhusu somo hili kinaweza kuwa ushahidi, kisa au sahihisho katika toleo lijalo, kikitajwa kwa jina lako na kuchapishwa chini ya CC BY 4.0 pale ambapo ni kazi yako mwenyewe.

Global Risks ForumDisaster and Crisis GovernanceUniverse Annual SynthesisEvidence Brief
Utawala wa Maafa na Majanga

Bring a governance question to the Forum.

Information and enquiries are open today. An enquiry receives a reference and names the next step; applications, payments, compute allocations and registrations open only when their team, terms and review capacity exist.