Skip to content

GRF · Disaster and Crisis Governance

Simulation and after action

Institutions learn about crises in two ways: by rehearsing them and by reviewing them. Simulation exercises test plans, relationships and decisions under controlled pressure; after-action reviews examine what happened in a real event. Both are useful only if lessons identified become changes made. This page sets out how exercises and reviews work and where learning fails, the records that show it, and who decides what changes.

01Canvas

How the work runs.

Systems · around this subjectIllustrative

Multi-agency coordination board

Simulation and after action · National crisis centre · Exercise EX-22

Coordination exerciseGRF · Disaster and Crisis Governance

Who leads what

WarningMeteorological serviceCivil protectionDuidelikActive
EvacuationMunicipalityPoliceOverlapTasked
ShelterSocial servicesVolunteer societyDuidelikActive
Public informationCrisis coordinatorAllGapUnassigned

Exercise log

  1. 09:00STAExercise start
  2. 09:44WRNRed warning issued
  3. 10:13GAPTwo agencies issue conflicting advice
  4. 11:00FIXSingle spokesperson named

After-action items

  1. AA-1Assign public information lead in lawPolicy owner55 d
  2. AA-2Shared situation picture between agenciesCrisis centre58 d
Multi-agency coordination board: the screen’s structure, terms and states for Simulation and after action.Example names and illustrative values; a design, not a record or a live system.

Fig.Multi-agency coordination board: example names and illustrative values, not a record or a live system.

02The question

Simulation and after action: how the risk develops.

Exercise governance and learning. The dossier below sets out how the risk develops, what is measured, where the data come from, how it is modelled and who decides.

Mechanism

Exercises confirm the plan

Exercises designed to succeed test the plan as written rather than its weak points. Severe, surprising scenarios reveal more, but they are uncomfortable for the organisations being tested.

Mechanism

Lessons are identified, not learned

Reviews produce recommendations that repeat across events. Without an owner, a deadline and follow-up, lessons stay in reports and the same failures recur.

Mechanism

Blame suppresses candour

If reviews are used to assign blame, participants withhold information. Separating learning reviews from accountability processes improves candour, but both are needed.

Mechanism

Learning stays in one agency

Lessons from one agency or country rarely travel. Shared repositories and joint reviews spread them, but only when someone is responsible for reading and acting on them.

03Geography

Hazards now in the Caribbean.

Flood water, population density and active fires over the Caribbean, from NASA GIBS. Each layer carries its own date.

Die interaktiewe kaart benodig JavaScript; die laaglys en bronne is hieronder.

Lae 3

Hazards now, for this page

Oor hierdie laag
Bewyse
Waargeneem (wolke laat gapings)
Bron
VIIRS Wêreldwye Vloedproduk (NASA LANCE)
Verskaffer
NASA LANCE
Lisensie
NASA-oopdata
Oesjaar
daagliks; Satellietopsporing; wolke laat gapings
Nuutste by bou
2026-10-14
Resolusie
ongeveer 250 m-rooster
Onsekerheid
Satellietopsporing; wolke laat gapings. Satelliet- of modelraster soos die verskaffer dit publiseer. Wolke, baangapings en herwinningsfoute laat gapings en geraas; waardes is aanwysers, nie metings op ’n plek nie.
Bereik deur
hierdie werf se data-aanstuurder, vanaf gibs.earthdata.nasa.gov
Oor hierdie laag
Bewyse
Geskat
Bron
Gridded Population of the World v4.11 (NASA SEDAC (CIESIN, Columbia-universiteit))
Verskaffer
NASA SEDAC (CIESIN, Columbia-universiteit)
Lisensie
CC BY 4.0
Oesjaar
null; Sensusgebaseerde skatting, staties (2020)
Resolusie
ongeveer 1 km-rooster
Onsekerheid
Sensusgebaseerde skatting van mense per vierkante kilometer in 2020, getoon as blootstellingskonteks; nie ’n telling van mense wat deur enige gevaar geraak word nie.
Bereik deur
hierdie werf se data-aanstuurder, vanaf gibs.earthdata.nasa.gov
Oor hierdie laag
Bewyse
Waargeneem (wolke en oorvlugtye laat gapings)
Bron
VIIRS NOAA-20 375 m (FIRMS) (NASA LANCE FIRMS)
Verskaffer
NASA LANCE FIRMS
Lisensie
NASA-oopdata
Oesjaar
daagliks; Satellietopsporing; wolke en oorvlugtye laat gapings
Nuutste by bou
2026-10-13
Resolusie
ongeveer 500 m-rooster
Onsekerheid
Satellietopsporings van hittekolle vir die getoonde dag, insluitend gasfakkels en industriële hitte; nie ’n bevestigde brand, ’n insidentverslag of ’n waarskuwing nie.
Bereik deur
hierdie werf se data-aanstuurder, vanaf gibs.earthdata.nasa.gov
Oor hierdie laag
Bewyse
Geskat
Bron
GPM IMERG (NASA GES DISC)
Verskaffer
NASA GES DISC
Lisensie
NASA-oopdata
Oesjaar
daily; Satellite estimate, near real time
Nuutste by bou
2026-10-12
Resolusie
ongeveer 2 km-rooster
Onsekerheid
Satellite estimate, near real time. Satellite or model raster as the provider publishes it. Clouds, swath gaps and retrieval error leave gaps and noise; values are indicators, not measurements at a place.
Bereik deur
hierdie werf se data-aanstuurder, vanaf gibs.earthdata.nasa.gov
Oor hierdie laag
Bewyse
Waargeneem
Bron
VIIRS Black Marble (VNP46A2) (NASA LAADS DAAC)
Verskaffer
NASA LAADS DAAC
Lisensie
NASA-oopdata
Oesjaar
daagliks; Satellietstraling, gekorrigeer vir maanlig en atmosfeer
Nuutste by bou
2026-10-12
Resolusie
ongeveer 500 m-rooster
Onsekerheid
Satelliet-nagstraling vir die getoonde datum; ligte is ’n benadering van elektrisiteitsgebruik en onderbrekings, nie ’n meting van voorsiening of toegang nie.
Bereik deur
hierdie werf se data-aanstuurder, vanaf gibs.earthdata.nasa.gov
Oor hierdie laag
Bewyse
Waargeneem
Bron
VIIRS NOAA-20 corrected reflectance (NASA LANCE)
Verskaffer
NASA LANCE
Lisensie
NASA-oopdata
Oesjaar
daily; Satellite image
Nuutste by bou
2026-10-14
Resolusie
ongeveer 250 m-rooster
Onsekerheid
Satellite image. Satellite or model raster as the provider publishes it. Clouds, swath gaps and retrieval error leave gaps and noise; values are indicators, not measurements at a place.
Bereik deur
hierdie werf se data-aanstuurder, vanaf gibs.earthdata.nasa.gov

Nuutste beskikbaar

NASA GIBS / EOSDIS · ASTER GDEM (METI, NASA) · Blue Marble (NASA) · © OpenStreetMap-bydraers (ODbL) · Natural Earth

Laai tans die nuutste NASA-beelde.

Sleep om te skuif. Ctrl of ⌘ en rol, knyp of die knoppies om te zoem; sweef vir die waardes onder die wyser; terugstel keer terug na die streek.

Hazards now, framed on the Caribbean.Satellite and model products as NASA publishes them, each with its own date. They are indicators, not assessments of any place.

Gegewens: NASA GIBS · ASTER GDEM · Blue Marble · © OpenStreetMap-bydraers · Natural Earth · NASA EONET · Amerikaanse Geologiese OpnameBronne en lisensies

  • We acknowledge the use of imagery provided by services from NASA’s Global Imagery Browse Services (GIBS), part of NASA’s Earth Science Data and Information System (ESDIS). Colours redrawn from the published colour map; values averaged into hexagonal cells where shown (modified). NASA open data
  • We acknowledge the use of imagery provided by services from NASA’s Global Imagery Browse Services (GIBS), part of NASA’s Earth Science Data and Information System (ESDIS). Colours redrawn from the published colour map; values averaged into hexagonal cells where shown (modified). NASA open data
  • VIIRS near-real-time products (flood, land surface temperature, snow cover, corrected reflectance), NASA LANCE; imagery via NASA GIBS. Colours redrawn from the published colour map; values averaged into hexagonal cells where shown (modified). NASA open data
  • Center for International Earth Science Information Network (CIESIN), Columbia University. 2018. Gridded Population of the World, Version 4 (GPWv4): Population Density, Revision 11. NASA Socioeconomic Data and Applications Center (SEDAC). Licensed under CC BY 4.0. Colours redrawn from the published colour map; values averaged into hexagonal cells where shown (modified). doi:10.7927/H49C6VHW. CC BY 4.0
  • NASA Fire Information for Resource Management System (FIRMS), VIIRS 375 m active fire product, NASA LANCE; vector tiles via NASA GIBS. Colours redrawn from the published colour map; values averaged into hexagonal cells where shown (modified). NASA open data
  • GPM IMERG precipitation, NASA Precipitation Processing System; distributed by the NASA Goddard Earth Sciences Data and Information Services Center (GES DISC); imagery via NASA GIBS. Colours redrawn from the published colour map; values averaged into hexagonal cells where shown (modified). NASA open data
  • VIIRS Black Marble night-time lights, NASA Goddard Space Flight Center; distributed by the NASA Level-1 and Atmosphere Archive and Distribution System (LAADS DAAC); imagery via NASA GIBS. Colours redrawn from the published colour map; values averaged into hexagonal cells where shown (modified). NASA open data
  • ASTER GDEM is a product of METI and NASA (ASTER Global Digital Elevation Model V003, NASA LP DAAC); imagery via NASA GIBS. Colours redrawn from the published colour map; values averaged into hexagonal cells where shown (modified). Cite as: NASA/METI/AIST/Japan Spacesystems and U.S./Japan ASTER Science Team (2019). ASTER Global Digital Elevation Model V003. doi:10.5067/ASTER/ASTGTM.003. NASA open data
  • Gemaak met Natural Earth. Gratis vektor- en rasterkaartdata @ naturalearthdata.com. Openbare domein
  • © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL), via NASA GIBS (coastlines, boundaries, roads and place names). Colours redrawn from the published colour map; values averaged into hexagonal cells where shown (modified). ODbL
  • Blue Marble, NASA Earth Observatory; imagery via NASA GIBS. Colours redrawn from the published colour map; values averaged into hexagonal cells where shown (modified). NASA open data
  • Konteks op die aardbol en platkaart: kuslyne, grense, paaie en plekname uit NASA GIBS-verwysingslae (OpenStreetMap-data, ODbL, © OpenStreetMap contributors); Blue Marble-beelde as 'n opsionele basis; 3D-terrein en die hoogte-aflesing vanaf die ASTER GDEM-hoogtekleurindeks (klasse van 5 m tot 200 m, vir leesbaarheid oordryf). Grense word geteken soos gepubliseer en impliseer geen standpunt oor enige gebied nie.
  • Lewende gebeure: NASA Earth Observatory Natural Event Tracker (EONET); gebeure is aanduidend en behou hul oorspronklike bronskakels.
  • Lewend: NASA EONET. Gebeure is aanduidend, nie owerheidswaarskuwings nie.
  • Lewend: U.S. Geological Survey. Gebeure is aanduidend, nie owerheidswaarskuwings nie.
  • NASA GIBS: Ons erken die gebruik van beelde verskaf deur dienste van NASA se Global Imagery Browse Services (GIBS), deel van NASA se Earth Science Data and Information System (ESDIS).
  • Riviervloeivoorspelling, 30 dae met omvang (GloFAS via Open-Meteo): bevat gewysigde Copernicus Emergency Management Service-inligting 2026; nie 'n vloedwaarskuwing nie.
  • Weerdata deur Open-Meteo.com (https://open-meteo.com/), gelisensieer onder CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
  • Opsionele lae (20 bronne in die laaglys: lewend, voorspelling, waargeneem en konteks) druk hul verskaffererkenning op die kaart en hier af wanneer hulle aangeskakel word; voorspellings is modeluitsette en afgeleide indekse is skattings.

Lae en datums

  • Vloedwater, 3-dae-saamgestelde beeld: VIIRS Global Flood Product, NASA LANCE · 14 Okt. 2026
  • Population density, 2020: Population: CIESIN, Columbia University, Gridded Population of the World v4.11 (2018), NASA SEDAC, CC BY 4.0 · static
  • Aktiewe brande en termiese afwykings: VIIRS NOAA-20 375 m (FIRMS), NASA LANCE FIRMS · 13 Oktober 2026
  • Neerslagtempo, daaglikse gemiddelde: GPM IMERG, NASA GES DISC · 12 Okt. 2026
  • Naglig, daagliks: VIIRS Black Marble (VNP46A2), NASA LAADS DAAC · 12 Okt. 2026
  • Ware kleur: VIIRS NOAA-20 gekorrigeerde weerkaatsing, NASA LANCE · 13 Oktober 2026

04Aanwysers

What is measured, and how well.

Each indicator carries its unit, its cadence, the kind of source behind it and the evidence label a value would carry. No values are shown: a programme supplies them under its own authority.

IndicatorUnitCadenceSource typeLabel
Exercises conductedcount per year, by type and levelannualExercise programme recordsREPORTED
Exercises involving several agencies or sectorsshare of exercisesannualExercise recordsREPORTED
After-action reviews completed after major eventsshare of events reviewedannualAgency recordsREPORTED
Recommendations implementedshare of recommendations closed with evidenceannualFollow-up reportsREPORTED
Repeat findings across reviewscount of recurring issuesperiodicReview analysisESTIMATED
Joint external evaluations or simulation exercises under IHRcountperiodicWHO recordsPublished statistics
05Twin and cascade simulator

Exercise a cascade in simulation and after action with the people who decide.

Assembled from the Nexus Standards area profile Early warning and anticipatory action: the hazards it names, the systems and communities that carry the loss, the controls and institutions that dampen it and the data that observe it. Pick an initiating event and step through the cascade to see where mandates meet and which decisions fall to whom. The Map view places the run on an example geography with open data. Every weight is a stated assumption. An exercise for dialogue, not a forecast, an assessment or a position. To model a place of your own choosing, open the full System Builder.

Gevare

  • Ice-jam flood
  • Tropical cyclone
  • Hittegolf
  • HIV epidemic
  • Storm surge (set off downstream)
  • Intense rainfall (set off downstream)
  • River flood (set off downstream)
  • Flash flood (set off downstream)
  • Dangerous surf (set off downstream)
  • Widespread power outage (set off downstream)
  • Mass displacement (set off downstream)
  • Coastal flood (set off downstream)
  • Extreme fire weather (set off downstream)
  • Wildfire (set off downstream)
  • Heat-driven grid stress (set off downstream)
  • Agricultural drought (set off downstream)
  • Flash drought (set off downstream)
  • Snow drought (set off downstream)

Controls

  • NS-0 Grondwet en beginsels
  • NS-3 Risikorekord-UNI's (grammatika, oorerflike kruisverwysing, toewysingsgesag)
  • NS-9 Kontekstuele UNI's (ontplooiings, instansies, programinstansies)
  • NS-10 Policies and clauses (machine-readable obligations: definition, binding, evaluation and enforcement)
  • NS-11 Verifikasie en monitering (getuienis, attestasies, zero-trust-ooreenstemmingwaarneming)
  • NRS-C7 Early warning, triggers and anticipatory action
  • NRS-S9 System profile: NXS-AAP (Anticipatory action and triggers)
  • NRS-H117 Hazard family: Social cohesion and atrocity risk (NHS-1 soc.cohesion)
  • NRS-H83 Hazard family: Health system capacity failure (NHS-1 health.system)
  • NRS-H98 Hazard family: Agentic AI acting at scale (NHS-1 tech.ai-agentic)
  • NRS-H22 Hazard family: Solar-terrestrial storms (NHS-1 space.solar-storm)

Observation

  • NWS API active alerts (CAP 1.2 as GeoJSON) (listed for reference)
  • GloFAS global flood forecasts and reanalysis (listed for reference)
  • ECMWF open data (IFS and AIFS real-time forecasts) (listed for reference)
  • CHIRPS quasi-global gridded precipitation (listed for reference)
  • Number of countries that have multi-hazard early warning systems
  • Number of countries that have multi-hazard monitoring and forecasting systems
  • Number of people per 100,000 covered by early warning information through local governments or national dissemination mechanisms
  • Number of countries with accessible, understandable, usable and relevant disaster risk information and assessment

Example geography

  • Southeast Asia: 51 hexagonal cells
  • Surface water through cloud, 30 m (OPERA DSWx-S1 radar), NASA GIBS
  • Rain rate, last half hour (IMERG), NASA GIBS
  • Surface air temperature, daytime (AIRS), NASA GIBS
  • Night lights tonight, outages (VIIRS Day/Night Band), NASA GIBS
06Bronne

Where the evidence comes from.

Named public datasets and institutional records, each with its licence class. Sources by agreement are used only under their terms and never republished.

BronWhat it givesLicence class
WHO simulation exercise and after-action review guidance and reportsMethods and records of health emergency exercises and reviewsFree, WHO terms
FEMA Homeland Security Exercise and Evaluation Program (HSEEP)Exercise design and evaluation doctrineOpenbare domein
Public inquiry reportsIndependent reviews of major emergenciesPublic records, terms per inquiry
ALNAP evaluation libraryEvaluations of humanitarian responsesFree to read, terms per document
European Union Civil Protection Mechanism lessons learnt programme recordsExercises and lessons across participating statesPublic, EU reuse terms
07Instruments and commitments

How simulation and after action is governed: instruments, mandates and commitments.

The instruments, mandates, actors and accountability arrangements a policymaker, diplomat or development agency works with, citing the agreements that set them. Structures follow the frameworks named. Any state or progress drawn is illustrative, not a record.

Mandates and agreements over time

The agreements that set mandates and commitments on simulation and after action, from adoption to their current horizon.

  1. 2015Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk ReductionUNDRR
  2. 20152030 Agenda and the Sustainable Development GoalsUnited Nations
  3. 2030Horizon of the 2030 Agenda and the Sendai FrameworkUnited Nations
Adoption years of the agreements named; the texts and their bodies are the authority. Chosen from the page’s fields.
Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction · UNDRRParis Agreement · UNFCCC2030 Agenda and the Sustainable Development Goals · United NationsInternational Health Regulations · WHO
08Decisions

Who decides, and what the evidence serves.

Disaster and Crisis Governance prepares evidence. The decisions below are taken by the authorities named, under their own rules, and never by the platform.

Wie besluitThe questionEvidence this page serves
Emergency management agenciesWhich scenarios to exercise and how oftenExercise practice and recurring findings
Agency headsWhich recommendations to implement and with what resourcesReview findings and follow-up records
Legislatures and inquiry chairsWhether to commission an independent review and what it coversComparative inquiry practice
Health ministriesWhether to hold IHR simulation exercises and reviewsWHO guidance and exercise records

Outputs this topic produces

  • Guide to exercise types, from discussion to full-scale
  • Method note on tracking lessons from identification to change
  • Dialogue briefs on recurring findings across public inquiries
  • Questions for agencies designing exercise programmes
09Core questions

What governance experts ask.

Plans that have never been tested rarely work as written. Exercises reveal gaps in authority, communication, information and resources in a setting where mistakes cost nothing. But many exercises are designed to succeed rather than to find weaknesses, and many lessons are identified but never learned. The governance of exercises, who designs them, who sees the results and who acts on them, decides their value.

  • What are the objectives of an exercise, and are they designed to test real weaknesses?
  • Who participates, and does the exercise involve the decision-makers who would act in a real crisis?
  • How candid is the after-action review, and how are findings protected from being used to assign blame?
  • Who owns each follow-up action, and how is implementation tracked?
10Mechanisms

How the arrangements work.

Learning depends on exercise design, honest review and follow-through.

Design

Exercise types

Discussion-based tabletop exercises test decisions; functional and full-scale exercises test operations. Each serves different objectives.

Review

After-action learning

Structured reviews ask what was expected, what happened, why and what will change. A blame-free approach encourages candour.

Follow-through

Lessons learned

Actions with named owners and deadlines, tracked until complete. Many systems fail at this step.

The distinction between lessons identified and lessons learned is central. An after-action report that lists problems is only the first step; learning happens when procedures, training, resources or structures change and the change is tested in a later exercise. Governance arrangements that assign ownership of each lesson, and that report publicly on progress where possible, make that cycle visible.

Why now: public inquiries, including the United Kingdom COVID-19 Inquiry’s first module report (2024), found that exercise lessons had been identified but not implemented. The platform is designed to apply established exercise practice, such as the WHO Simulation Exercise Manual (2017) and after action review guidance (2019), and to track each improvement item to its owner.

11Methods and evidence

How the evidence is built, and its limits.

  1. 01

    Exercise evaluation

    Observation against objectives during exercises. Evaluators need independence and expertise.

  2. 02

    Lessons databases

    Collections of lessons across events and exercises. Useful only if searched and acted upon.

  3. 03

    Simulation models

    Computer simulations of crisis dynamics, applying optimisation and operations research and decision analysis under uncertainty. They support exercises but cannot replace human decision-making practice.

  4. 04

    Longitudinal tracking

    Following whether the same issues recur across events, which indicates whether learning is happening.

12Metodes

How it is studied, and what the methods cannot say.

  1. Decision analysis under uncertaintyWarning thresholds and false alarms · Pre-agreed triggers for actionApplied here
  2. Optimisation and operations researchPre-positioning relief stocks · Evacuation and relief routing · Sequencing recovery investmentApplied here
  3. Policy, institutional and decision scienceComparing emergency law · Tracing recurring findings · Mapping coordination structuresApplied here
13Vrae

Questions and answers.

What is an after-action review?
A structured review of what was planned, what happened, why, and what should change, held after an exercise or a real event. WHO and many emergency agencies publish guidance for it.
What types of exercise are there?
Discussion-based exercises such as seminars and tabletop exercises, and operations-based exercises such as drills, functional exercises and full-scale exercises.
Why do the same lessons recur?
Because recommendations often lack an owner, resources and follow-up, and because organisational turnover erases memory. Tracking lessons to closure addresses this.
What makes an exercise useful?
Clear objectives, realistic scenarios, participation of real decision-makers, honest review and tracked follow-up actions.
Why are lessons often not learned?
Because findings lack owners, resources or follow-up, or because reviews avoid uncomfortable conclusions. Tracking implementation addresses this.
Are exercise results published?
At a public-safe level, without assessing individuals and only with participating institutions’ agreement on what is released.
Does the Universe exercise replace national exercises?
No. It complements them and has no authority over any national exercise programme.
VerslaeDra by

Dra bewyse vanaf hierdie bladsy by.

Reports is the Consortium’s quarterly publication. What you know about this subject can become evidence, a case or a correction in the next edition, credited to you and published under CC BY 4.0 where it is your own work.

Global Risks ForumDisaster and Crisis GovernanceUniverse Annual SynthesisEvidence Brief
Ramp- en krisisbeheer

Bring a governance question to the Forum.

Information and enquiries are open today. An enquiry receives a reference and names the next step; applications, payments, compute allocations and registrations open only when their team, terms and review capacity exist.