GRF · Institutional dialogues
对话方法
A dialogue is only as fair as its procedure. The Global Risks Forum (GRF) designs dialogues so every institution sharing the risk is in the room, voices with less power are heard, disagreement is kept and the record can be trusted. The practice draws on the OECD Good Practice Principles for Deliberative Processes (2020), the IAP2 spectrum, the Chatham House Rule, and free, prior and informed consent.
The workspace for dialogue methods.
审议台
成员理事会 · 第 4 轮,共 5 轮 · 示例界面,并非记录
审议
- 界定问题已商定
- 证据简报独立
- 听取立场全体成员
- 备选方案附权衡取舍
- 建议理由
- 决定职责承担方
立场
| 成员国 A | 支持 | 中立 | 对象 | 资金方面的担忧 |
| 成员国 B | 中立 | 支持 | 支持 | |
| 区域机构 | 支持 | 支持 | 中立 | 倾向于分阶段 |
| 公民社会 | 对象 | 支持 | 支持 | 公平 |
规则
- 法定人数
- 2/3
- 异议
- 已附理由记录
- 证据
- 简报 EB-64
- 决定
- not GRF’s
GRF · 审议台。 审议台:示例名称和示意性数值,并非记录。
Six steps from question to record.
- 01
界定问题
A question participants can answer, with its scope, the decisions it may inform and the participation level: inform, consult, involve or collaborate.
- 02
绘制风险分担方图谱
主管部门、运营方、受影响社区、证据持有方以及将依据结果采取行动的各方,依据依赖关系图而非宾客名单确定。
- 03
附条款邀请
邀请函会说明目的、署名规则、会议的记录方式,以及参与者如何退出。
- 04
申报利益
参与者申报相关利益,并在会议前处理利益冲突。
- 05
主持会议
A facilitator protects time for every constituency and logs agreements, commitments, open questions and dissent as they arise.
- 06
Check and release
参与者在规定期限内审阅记录草稿;发布后的更正将作为新版本保留。
促进方法及各自所保护的内容。
| 方法 | 功能 | What it protects against |
|---|---|---|
| 会前分发的问题与证据简报 | 让每个人从相同的事实出发 | 资源充足与资源较少的参与者之间的不对称 |
| 轮流首轮发言 | Every institution speaks before open debate | Domination by the most senior voice |
| Structured disagreement log | Records each objection with its holder’s reasoning | 虚假共识 |
| 德尔菲式匿名轮次 | 在没有地位压力的情况下收集专家判断 | Anchoring on early or senior opinions |
| Interpretation and plain-language summaries | 跨语言和学科适用 | 因词汇造成的排除 |
流程如何运行。
Process explorer · Process
对话方法:贯穿八道关口的方案
11 个步骤·4 个阶段·8 道关口
流程
对话方法:贯穿八道关口的方案
GRF 记录每年八道关口,每道关口都是一项计划决定;未通过的关口会终止其相关工作,主管当局在计划之外作出决定。
01 第1季度 · 规划
- 01G0 · 年度计划获授权关口 · Global Risks ForumGRF 授权年度任务。它从不设定国家议程。
- 03Route the candidate mission to standardsStep · Nexus StandardsNexus Standards routes each candidate mission to the standards and profiles that apply.
02 第2季度 · 就绪与构建
- 04G1 · 任务获准入关口 · Global Risks ForumGRF 接纳任务时会记录理由。没有负责的所有者,它就不能接纳任务。
- 05G2 · 数据和资源已通过资格审查关口 · Global Risks Forum当数据、人员和资源均合格时,准备度筹备即告结束。
- 06G3 · 构建被接受用于演练关口 · Global Risks ForumGRF 记录构建是否被接受用于演练。未通过的关口会叫停其所管辖的工作。
03 Q3 · 行动周
- 07G4 · 受控实际运行获授权关口 · Global Risks ForumGRF 授权在行动周期间进行受控的实际运行。
- 08G5 · 证据已封存,解除待命已记录关口 · Global Risks Forum证据连同其来源追溯一并封存,并记录撤场情况。
04 第4季度 · 报告与更新
- 02主管当局作出决定并采取行动行动方 · 主管当局主管当局依据其自身规则作出决定并采取行动。项目为其提供信息,绝不替其作决定。
- 09科学与编辑审查步骤 · 审查人员和发布方由具备资质、已管理利益冲突的审查人员和发布方决定接受哪些内容。机构不能决定科学结论。
- 10G6 · 发布获授权关口 · Global Risks ForumGRF 授权发布已通过科学审查和编辑审查的结果。它不能发布个人数据。
- 11G7 · Renewal reviewedGate · The Global Risks ForumGRF reviews renewal and sets the next cycle’s mandate.
The programme year · The Global Risks Forum · Decision rightsDesigned programme process, not a record of operation. No cycle has run and every programme is at service level R0. A gate is a programme decision, never a public-authority approval, certification or deployment authorisation.
GRF 借鉴的实践。
- The OECD Good Practice Principles for Deliberative Processes: clear purpose, accountability for the response, transparency, representativeness, inclusiveness, information, group deliberation, time, integrity, privacy, evaluation.
- The IAP2 spectrum of public participation, to be explicit about whether a session informs, consults, involves, collaborates or empowers.
- Free, prior and informed consent where Indigenous peoples’ rights and lands are concerned, following UNDRIP.
Which level of the participation spectrum a dialogue sits at is stated in its invitation, so no participant mistakes a consultation for a decision.
Protecting voices with less power.
权利持有者优先
Community and Indigenous institutions take part on agreed terms, choose their own representatives, and protected knowledge is used only under an agreed schedule.
Barriers removed
形式、语言、口译和时间的选择,应使参与不取决于差旅预算或资历。
Safeguarding by design
Students, volunteers and community members are never exposed to pressure or retaliation for what they say.
How evidence is used without becoming a verdict.
Dialogues work best when everyone starts from the same facts. An evidence brief goes out before the session. Each statement carries its evidence class, such as observed, modelled, scenario or expert judgement, and its publisher. Scientific work comes from its publisher, such as The Global Centre for Risk and Innovation (GCRI), under GCRI scientific and editorial integrity. A range stays a range. A scenario is never read as a forecast. The facilitator keeps the discussion on the decision and records where participants read the evidence differently.
对话记录绝不会提升证据等级。会议中讨论的模型估算,在记录中仍然是模型估算。
记录如何保持诚信。
- Silence is never recorded as agreement.
- 异议与共识同样审慎地记录,仅在征得同意后署名。
- 承诺注明作出承诺的机构及其选定的后续跟进日期。
- 受限部分不予公开,记录会对此加以说明。
- 发起方或主办方不得批准或更改该记录。
仅在获得同意的情况下,记录才会进入后续步骤:年度计划的演练提案、Reports 中引用的研究结果,或依据 Nexus Standards 制定流程提出的变更提案。参见 对话成果.
Where this page’s references lead.
阅读本页时所对照的机构和文件。状态和版本会变化;每个链接都指向发布机构。
问题与解答。
谁来主持 GRF 对话?
我可以不具名发言吗?
如果我不同意记录草稿怎么办?
Is a consultation a decision?
这些方法对每次对话都相同吗?
法律文件。
显示全部 18 份法律文件
本网站上的地图、数据和图表仅作为背景和一般信息展示。它们不是建议、预测或预警;信息的局限见免责声明和数据说明。