Skip to content

GRF · Institutional dialogues

Dialogue methods

A dialogue is only as fair as its procedure. The Global Risks Forum (GRF) designs dialogues so every institution sharing the risk is in the room, voices with less power are heard, disagreement is kept and the record can be trusted. The practice draws on the OECD Good Practice Principles for Deliberative Processes (2020), the IAP2 spectrum, the Chatham House Rule, and free, prior and informed consent.

01کارگاہ

The workspace for dialogue methods.

Deliberation desk

Council of members · Round 4 of 5 · Example interface, not a record

Options under deliberationGRF · GRF

غور و خوض

  1. Frame the questionagreed
  2. Evidence briefindependent
  3. Hear positionsall members
  4. Optionswith trade-offs
  5. Recommendreasons
  6. Decidemandate holder

Positions

Member state ASupportNeutralObjectFunding concern
Member state BNeutralSupportSupport
Regional bodySupportSupportNeutralPrefers phasing
Civil societyObjectSupportSupportEquity

قواعد

Quorum
2 thirds
Dissent
recorded with reasons
شواہد
brief EB-64
فیصلہ
not GRF’s
Deliberation desk.Illustrative interface; not live data.

GRF · Deliberation desk. Deliberation desk: example names and illustrative values, not a record.

02Procedure

Six steps from question to record.

  1. 01

    Frame the question

    A question participants can answer, with its scope, the decisions it may inform and the participation level: inform, consult, involve or collaborate.

  2. 02

    Map who shares the risk

    Authorities, operators, affected communities, evidence holders and those who will act on the outcome, drawn from a dependency map rather than a guest list.

  3. 03

    Invite with terms

    Invitations state the purpose, the attribution rule, how the session is recorded and how a participant can withdraw.

  4. 04

    Declare interests

    Participants declare relevant interests, and conflicts are managed before the session.

  5. 05

    Run the session

    A facilitator protects time for every constituency and logs agreements, commitments, open questions and dissent as they arise.

  6. 06

    Check and release

    Participants review the draft record within a stated period; corrections after release are kept as new versions.

03Toolkit

Facilitation methods and what each protects.

طریقہیہ کیا کرتا ہےWhat it protects against
Pre-circulated question and evidence briefGives everyone the same starting factsAsymmetry between well-resourced and less-resourced participants
Round-robin first statementsEvery institution speaks before open debateDomination by the most senior voice
Structured disagreement logRecords each objection with its holder’s reasoningFalse consensus
Delphi-style anonymous roundsCollects expert judgement without status pressureAnchoring on early or senior opinions
Interpretation and plain-language summariesWorks across languages and disciplinesExclusion by vocabulary
04عمل

عمل کیسے چلتا ہے۔

Process explorer · Process

Dialogue methods: Programme through eight gates

11 مراحل4 مراحل8 گیٹ

عمل

Dialogue methods: Programme through eight gates

GRF records eight yearly gates, each a programme decision; a gate not passed stops its work, and the competent authority decides outside.

  1. 01 سہ ماہی 1 · منصوبہ بندی

    1. 01G0 · سالانہ پروگرام کی اجازت دی گئیدروازہ · Global Risks ForumGRF سالانہ اختیار نامے کی اجازت دیتا ہے۔ یہ کبھی قومی ایجنڈا طے نہیں کرتا۔
    2. 03Route the candidate mission to standardsStep · Nexus StandardsNexus Standards routes each candidate mission to the standards and profiles that apply.
  2. 02 سہ ماہی 2 · تیاری اور تعمیر

    1. 04G1 · مشن داخل کیے گئےدروازہ · Global Risks ForumGRF درج شدہ وجوہات کے ساتھ مشن داخل کرتا ہے۔ یہ کسی جوابدہ مالک کے بغیر مشن داخل نہیں کر سکتا۔
    2. 05G2 · ڈیٹا اور وسائل اہل قرار دیے گئےدروازہ · Global Risks Forumتیاری کی تیاری اس وقت مکمل ہوتی ہے جب ڈیٹا، افراد اور وسائل اہل قرار پائیں۔
    3. 06G3 · مشق کے لیے تعمیر قبول کی گئیدروازہ · Global Risks ForumGRF درج کرتا ہے کہ آیا تعمیر مشق کے لیے قبول کی گئی۔ جو دروازہ پار نہ ہو وہ اپنے زیر انتظام کام کو روک دیتا ہے۔
  3. 03 سہ ماہی 3 · ایکشن ہفتہ

    1. 07G4 · کنٹرول شدہ براہ راست کارروائی کی اجازت دی گئیدروازہ · Global Risks ForumGRF ایکشن ہفتے کے لیے کنٹرول شدہ براہ راست کارروائی کی اجازت دیتا ہے۔
    2. 08G5 · شواہد مہر بند اور اختتام درجدروازہ · Global Risks Forumشواہد اپنے ماخذ کے ساتھ مہر بند کیے جاتے ہیں اور اختتام درج کیا جاتا ہے۔
  4. 04 سہ ماہی 4 · رپورٹنگ اور تجدید

    1. 02مجاز ادارہ فیصلہ کرتا ہے اور عمل کرتا ہےفریق · مجاز ادارہمجاز ادارہ اپنے قواعد کے تحت فیصلہ اور عمل کرتا ہے۔ پروگرام اسے معلومات دیتا ہے اور کبھی اس کی جگہ فیصلہ نہیں کرتا۔
    2. 09سائنسی اور ادارتی جائزہمرحلہ · جائزہ کار اور ناشراہل، مفادات کے تصادم سے پاک جائزہ کار اور ناشر طے کرتے ہیں کہ کیا قبول ہو۔ ادارے کسی سائنسی نتیجے کا فیصلہ نہیں کر سکتے۔
    3. 10G6 · اشاعت کی اجازت دی گئیدروازہ · Global Risks ForumGRF ان نتائج کی اشاعت کی اجازت دیتا ہے جو سائنسی اور ادارتی جائزے سے گزر چکے ہوں۔ یہ ذاتی ڈیٹا شائع نہیں کر سکتا۔
    4. 11G7 · Renewal reviewedGate · The Global Risks ForumGRF reviews renewal and sets the next cycle’s mandate.

The programme year · The Global Risks Forum · Decision rightsDesigned programme process, not a record of operation. No cycle has run and every programme is at service level R0. A gate is a programme decision, never a public-authority approval, certification or deployment authorisation.

05Reference standards

Practice GRF draws on.

  • The OECD Good Practice Principles for Deliberative Processes: clear purpose, accountability for the response, transparency, representativeness, inclusiveness, information, group deliberation, time, integrity, privacy, evaluation.
  • The IAP2 spectrum of public participation, to be explicit about whether a session informs, consults, involves, collaborates or empowers.
  • Free, prior and informed consent where Indigenous peoples’ rights and lands are concerned, following UNDRIP.

Which level of the participation spectrum a dialogue sits at is stated in its invitation, so no participant mistakes a consultation for a decision.

06Fair inclusion

Protecting voices with less power.

Communities

Rights-holders first

Community and Indigenous institutions take part on agreed terms, choose their own representatives, and protected knowledge is used only under an agreed schedule.

Access

Barriers removed

Formats, languages, interpretation and timing are chosen so that participation does not depend on travel budgets or seniority.

Safety

Safeguarding by design

Students, volunteers and community members are never exposed to pressure or retaliation for what they say.

07Evidence in the room

How evidence is used without becoming a verdict.

Dialogues work best when everyone starts from the same facts. An evidence brief goes out before the session. Each statement carries its evidence class, such as observed, modelled, scenario or expert judgement, and its publisher. Scientific work comes from its publisher, such as The Global Centre for Risk and Innovation (GCRI), under GCRI scientific and editorial integrity. A range stays a range. A scenario is never read as a forecast. The facilitator keeps the discussion on the decision and records where participants read the evidence differently.

A dialogue record never upgrades evidence. A modelled estimate discussed in a session is still a modelled estimate in the record.

08Recording rules

How the record stays honest.

  • Silence is never recorded as agreement.
  • Dissent is recorded with the same care as agreement, attributed only with consent.
  • Commitments name the institution that made them and the follow-up date it chose.
  • Restricted parts are withheld and the record says so.
  • A sponsor or host cannot approve or change the record.

Records feed the next steps only with consent: an exercise proposal for the annual programme, a finding cited in Reports, or a change proposal under the Nexus Standards development process. See Dialogue outcomes.

09ماخذات

Where this page’s references lead.

وہ ادارے اور دستاویزات جن کے تناظر میں یہ صفحہ پڑھا جاتا ہے۔ حیثیت اور ایڈیشن بدلتے رہتے ہیں؛ ہر لنک جاری کرنے والے ادارے تک جاتا ہے۔

10سوالات

سوالات و جوابات۔

Who facilitates a GRF dialogue?
A facilitator appointed by GRF for the session, who declares interests and does not represent any participant.
Can I speak without being named?
Yes. Attribution in a record requires consent, and the Chatham House Rule applies where the invitation says so. A view can be recorded without a name.
What if I disagree with the draft record?
Raise it during the review period. If the disagreement remains, it is noted in the record. After release, corrections go to the integrity concern form.
Is a consultation a decision?
No. The invitation states the participation level. A consultation gathers views; any decision stays with the competent institution under its own procedure.
Are these methods the same for every dialogue?
The steps are the same. The format scales with the question, and any departure is stated in the record. Outcomes are explained on Dialogue outcomes.
Global Risks Forum

Bring a governance question to the Forum.

معلومات اور استفسارات آج کھلے ہیں۔ استفسار کو ایک حوالہ نمبر ملتا ہے اور اگلے مرحلے کی نشاندہی ہوتی ہے؛ درخواستیں، ادائیگیاں، کمپیوٹنگ کی تخصیص اور رجسٹریشن صرف اس وقت کھلتی ہیں جب ان کی ٹیم، شرائط اور جائزے کی استعداد موجود ہو۔